Alaska voters turned on Trump/Republican brand, while Sullivan flailed
After the election the experts have all the answers about what happened and why. The conclusions seem so obvious with the benefit of hindsight, though two weeks ago everything was different.
The New York Times has the best analysis today of Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska, aided in no small part by the contribution of long-time Alaska public radio reporter Emily Schwing. Here is the Times report.
I do think the wiggle words “may not have” in the lead paragraph are wrong, however. Peltola never needed two Dan Sullivans on the ballot. She won the election and Sullivan lost, though it remains to be seen if he will keep his promise to accept the results.
The Washington Post has a decent story on the contest as well, aided by the contribution of long-time Alaska journalist Julia O’Malley in Anchorage. Here is the Post report.
The Washington Sun’s report is also worth reading.
The newspapers rounded up the usual suspects to deliver perfect 20/20 hindsight about what Alaskans were thinking—Ashley Reed, Art Hackney, John-Henry Heckendorn and Joelle Hall.
The experts never announce any of this in advance, in part because they aren’t paid to do that and in part because no one really knows what will happen until it happens.
I think the quote by Heckendorn that best explains Sullivan’s defeat appeared in the Times.
Sullivan campaigned on how much money he has brought to Alaska, how important it was to keep the Senate in Republican hands and that he is a retired Marine who wants more military spending. He had a handful of simple talking points that he repeated in a mechanical manner.
For the past decade Sullivan has attached himself to the Trump circus without a murmur of opposition, even while prices soared in Alaska because of the war in Iran and the president dreamed of his ballroom.
Sullivan’s apologists have long said that he couldn’t even whisper about Trump’s deficiencies because Trump would say mean things about Sullivan. This highlights the character flaws in both men.
Sullivan advertising himself as the fearless Marine, promoting Trump as the all-powerful leader, while cowering in silence.
Of Sullivan, Democratic strategist Heckendorn told the Times, “He didn’t know what to do in a campaign where the Republican brand wasn’t going to save him.”
The Trump brand is the Republican brand.
As to Peltola, Heckendorn told the Post, “She fixed the campaign on Alaskan issues versus hyperpartisan national issues. That’s allowed her to pull together a coalition across party lines that could actually compete with MAGA.”
Hackney now says that Sullivan didn’t effectively counter the attacks from Peltola. “I don’t think Dan’s campaign inoculated himself well” against the attacks, Hackney told the Times.
An anonymous source in Sullivan’s campaign “argued instead that the national environment was the main culprit in Mr. Sullivan’s loss.”
That is some anonymous wishful thinking. It was the national environment plus Sullivan’s inability to change his message or his approach to Trump that were the main culprits in his defeat.